Skip to content
One live critique on the house — no sign-up. Try it
Deskcrit

Critique that argues back.

Everyone who's seen your screen is either too nice or too vague. Deskcrit is neither. In about a minute it ranks what's broken, proves it against your pixels, and when you push back, defends the call or concedes it — on the record.

Critique my screen — free Request an invite
3
3
Bottom tap targets measure under the 44px minimumMedium74%FITTS · HIG

Challenge #3: the real hit area extends past the glyph — it's 48px.

Re-examinedFair — if the tappable bounds are 48px, this passes. Downgrading to low pending evidence.
Revised · Medium → Low

THE SIGNATURE MOVE, PERFORMING ITSELF

Every finding is grounded in a named method.

NN/G 10 HEURISTICSWCAG-CITED EVIDENCECALIBRATED CONFIDENCECHALLENGE PROTOCOL

Critique, not commentary.

Chatbots comment. Deskcrit critiques:

Severity
ranked, never listed
Evidence
measured from your pixels
Confidence
honest about uncertainty
The fix
actionable as written
1
Two competing primary CTAs are styled identicallyHigh92%
WHY I FLAGGED THIS

Both buttons share the same fill, size, and weight, so the screen offers no default path. At the moment of decision, equal-weight choices measurably slow completion.

EVIDENCE

primary actions · identical fill · identical height

WHAT I'D DO

Pick one primary: keep a single filled button and demote the other to an outlined style — whichever converts better wins the fill.

Visual hierarchy · Hick's law

How it works.

  1. 01ReadsParses your screen into a context model — type, platform, intent — not just pixels.1 screen · context
  2. 02ReasonsThinks out loud through heuristic and craft passes. Visible, interruptible — no spinner theater.NN/g 10 · WCAG
  3. 03ReportsFindings ranked by severity, cited against the pixels, scored for confidence, closed with the smallest concrete fix.severity · evidence · confidence
  4. 04DefendsChallenge any finding. It engages your actual argument and resolves it on the record.defended · conceded · revised

Designers post screens into Slack and get emoji back.

Honest, senior critique is scarcest right before you ship. I spent twenty years reviewing screens for high-stakes platforms; Deskcrit encodes that judgment into an agent that holds its position under cross-examination. Transparently, it's also a portfolio artifact — the way this agent argues is my work sample.

Ravi Palweravipalwe.com

You've read this far. That's evidence of interest — confidence 92%.

Critique my screen — free
Critique my screen — free